Saturday October 15, 2011
MLB reports – Jonathan Hacohen: Only one game on the schedule last night- but it was a big one. The Brewers and Cardinals headed into game five in St. Louis, deadlocked at 2-2. With the series set to shift to Milwaukee, this was a big game to take the lead in the NLCS. With two strong pitchers on the mound, this game could have been a pitching duel. It was far from it and the resulting game surprised many. Here is a recap of last night’s NLCS action:
Milwaukee Brewers at St. Louis Cardinals: NLCS Game Five
From the title of this article, many readers will take it that the Cardinals won last night. Indeed they did, a strong 7-1 victory over the Brewers to take a 3-2 NLCS series lead. This game came down to key factors in my estimation: the in-game managing by Tony La Russa and the sloppy play of the Brewers. When referring to La Russa, the talk of last night was the call to the bullpen in the 5th inning. With the Cardinals up 4-1, the Brewers were threatening with 2 on and 2 out. Ryan Braun headed to the plate and La Russa ran to the mound. Cardinals starter Jaime Garcia was stellar up to that point, with 4 2/3 IP, 1 ER, 7 hits, 0 BB and 5 strikeouts. But as noted by last night’s television commentators, Garcia was starting to get into trouble. With one Brewers run already in and the hits starting to pile up, La Russa appeared to be nervous that his starter was losing it. Few managers would take out his starter at that point, but then few managers are Tony La Russa. With his bullpen on fire in this postseason, La Russa was not going to take any chances. Octavio Dotel got the call and proceeded to strike out Ryan Braun to end the threat. From there, Lance Lynn, Marc Rzepczynski and Jason Motte came on to shut out the Brewers on 2 hits and 1 walk. Motte finished up the game for the save with Dotel taking the win.
But that is not the end of the story. Far from it. As much as this game is about the wizardry of La Russa managing his pitching staff (along with trusty pitching coach Dave Duncan at his side), game five was also about the Brewers throwing it away. Literally. To me, Milwaukee was a team intent on giving the game away. Four errors on the night is completely unacceptable, especially for a game of this magnitude. It is not like the team was not hitting, as the Brewers had 9 hits compared to the Cardinals 10. Interestingly enough the Cardinals had 20 LOB, compared to the Brewers 14. But the Cardinals drove runners in when in it counted. Here is my logic in a game that came down to inches. Zack Greinke
gave up 5 runs, although only 2 of them were earned. Marco Estrada
in the 8th was a complete train-wreck, giving up 2 runs on 1 hit an 2 walks. Estrada completely was not finding the zone and was lucky to escape with only the 2 runs allowed. Take out the Estrada inning and Greinke’s 3 unearned runs, and you are now left with a 2-1 Cardinals lead. Thus the Cardinals victory relied on La Russa’s management, strong bullpen and Brewers lack of execution and poor play. A game of inches.
Greinke was good, but not great in this one. In 5 2/3 IP, Greinke gave up 7 hits and 2 walks. But he was not able to strikeout a batter. Even without his best stuff, Greinke did keep his team in this one and deserved a better fate. Had he received the defensive support he needed, Greinke could have stayed longer in this one and the game may have turned out differently. With a 5-1 score going into the 7th, the Brewers seemed deflated and defeated. Not the way to win ballgames folks.
Did Tony La Russa overreact by pulling his starter early? We will never know. Had Braun connected for a 3-run home run off Dotel and evened up the score, La Russa would have been the goat. But by Dotel striking out Braun, La Russa is a genius. The bottom line is that the Cardinals are one win away from going back to the World Series against a favored Brewers squad. I find that critics are too quick to pounce on major league managers when they make mistakes, but not fast enough to give credit when they make the right moves. La Russa doesn’t manage always by the book and has taken many chances in this postseason. Last night was no exception. Without the Brewers uneven play and the strong pitching of the Cardinals pen, the game may not have gone in the Cardinals favor. But the stars did align and Tony La Russa does deserve his due in this one. In a game of inches and trying to minimize mistakes, the Cardinals played sound baseball while the Brewers did not. Cardinals win and go on to Milwaukee for game six with the 3-2 edge.
ALCS and NLCS: Game Six Previews
Game six of the ALCS goes tonight in Texas, 8:05 PM ET is the scheduled start time. Max Scherzer
goes for the Tigers, Derek Holland
for the Rangers. Many are counting on this one going seven, as Scherzer has been steadier than Holland in the postseason. But then Holland is due for a big game. With the big Rangers bats at home, anything can happen in this one. Jim Leyland and Ron Washington will pulling out all the stops tonight. This one will be a classic. Over the in the National League, game 6 goes Sunday afternoon, 4:05 PM ET in Milwaukee. Shaun Marcum
and Edwin Jackson
are set to face-off. There was speculation that Marcum would be pulled given his poor play of late, but the Brewers are sticking with their starter. Jackson has been solid since coming over to St. Louis. With the momentum in the Cardinal’s favor, the Brewers will need a big game or face elimination on Sunday.
Jonathan Hacohen is the Lead Baseball Columnist & Editor for MLB reports
Please e-mail us at: MLBreports@gmail.com with any questions and feedback. You can follow us on Twitter and become a fan on Facebook . To subscribe to our website and have the daily Reports sent directly to your inbox , click here and follow the link at the top of our homepage.