John Farrell for Bobby Valentine: The Second Managerial Trade Ever?

Thursday August 23rd, 2012

Bernie Olshansky:  After the Red Sox cut ties with longtime manager Terry Francona, there were a few options for his replacement. Among those options were former pitching coach for the 2007 World Series Champion team John Farrell, and high-profile former-manager Bobby Valentine. Both seemed to be good options, and the Red Sox signed Valentine. Farrell won the managerial job with the Blue Jays after the retirement of Cito Gaston (Brian Butterfield, DeMarlo Hale, and Sandy Alomar, Jr. were also rumored to be vying for the position). Each team was poised to finish atop or close to the top of the AL East standings. This wasn’t the case for either team.

First I’ll cover the Red Sox. Their main problem was the lack of production. Adrian Gonzalez—who the Sox acquired to help carry the offense failed to produce at the beginning of the season. At the All Star Break, he had less than ten home runs. Jacoby Ellsbury was injured after only a few games, and the pitching was absolutely awful. Carl Crawford took a while to come back from his wrist and elbow injuries, and recently shut his season down to undergo Tommy John surgery. Jon Lester, the number one starter was up and down, and has had an off-year. Josh Beckett received boos after being accused of playing golf in between starts. There was obviously something wrong. The Red Sox fell out of contention fairly early—something that wasn’t expected. A lot of the criticism fell on the manager. Bobby Valentine was accused of demeaning the players, saying something along the lines of “nice inning, kid” to rookie Will Middlebrooks after he made an error. Another of Valentine’s slip-ups was calling into question Kevin Youkilis’ effort. This ultimately led to Youk being traded to the White Sox, ending his successful Red Sox career. Veterans such as Dustin Pedroia and Adrian Gonzalez didn’t take kindly to this and sent a text to management, spurring a meeting between front office officials and players. The situation in Boston is not good; players are divided into players versus manager and players versus players that support the manager. A change in Boston seems necessary; the pitching coach has already been relieved, and it seems like Bobby Valentine may be next.

The Blue Jays haven’t lived up to expectations either. This isn’t nearly the situation that the Red Sox are in, but a move might be necessary. The Blue Jays can say they lost this season to injuries. Brandon Morrow was placed on the DL with an oblique injury after putting up big numbers and pitching multiple shutouts. Jose Bautista and J.P. Arencibia both injured their wrists, and multiple other pitchers spent time on the DL. Meanwhile, Ricky Romero has had the worst season of his four-year career. Although they underperformed, the Blue Jays weren’t expected to be an AL East powerhouse. Firing the manager might not be the correct solution, but a change might be needed.

A unique solution to these problems could be swapping managers. This has only ever happened once before in Major League Baseball history (Aug of 1960 Cleveland Indians traded their Manager Joe Gordon to the Tigers in exchange for Jimmie Dykes going to the Indians.) Valentine needs to get out of Boston, so why not think about trading him and maybe Daniel Bard to Toronto? Bard has been a major disappointment for the Red Sox; he was expected to be a front-of-the-rotation starter but was sent to Triple-A. He has not regained his form since the demotion. The Red Sox could send Valentine and Bard to Toronto in return for Farrell. Boston would be getting the change they need (and a respected former Sox coach), and the Blue Jays would be getting a new manager and prized pitcher. The Red Sox could cover both managers’ contracts, and each team would profit. The Red Sox also wouldn’t risk alienating Jason Varitek—a suggested successor to Valentine. If Varitek were to take over for Valentine and the team was to be unsuccessful, he would be the one to take the fall.

Farrell (as reported by several media outlets) apparently has one more year left on his contract. So if the Blue Jays were to keep him, they could lose him for nothing next offseason. This could be the same situation as a player with an expiring contract being sent to a contending team as a “rent-a-player”. The Red Sox could try Farrell out next season and if he didn’t work out, the team could let his contract expire without any hard feelings. This would be a better situation than signing a Boston legend such as Jason Varitek and having the potential for all hell to break loose, leading to the catastrophic situation of having to cut ties with a revered former player.

Apparently Farrell is annoyed by the rumors, but a move like this could make both teams better. Valentine isn’t making the situation in Boston any better as he is rumored to be spending the majority of his time in his office—away from the players. A manager-for-manager trade would be somewhat out-of-the-ordinary, but one can always speculate. Hey…I just did!

(*The views and opinions expressed in this report are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of*)

***Today’s feature was prepared by Bernie Olshansky, Baseball Writer & Facebook Administrator.  We highly encourage you to leave your comments and feedback at the bottom of the page and share in the discussion with our readers.  You can also follow Bernie on Twitter (@BernieOlshansky)***

Please e-mail us at: with any questions and feedback.  You can follow us on Twitter and become a fan on Facebook .  To subscribe to our website and have the daily Reports sent directly to your inbox , click here and follow the link at the top of our homepage.

About bernieolshansky

Living in the San Francisco Bay Area, I’ve experienced some exciting times with the local baseball teams—the Giants winning the World Series being the most memorable highlight. Some of my favorite players include Felix Hernandez, Tim Lincecum, and Cliff Lee among others. I played baseball up through my freshman year of high school and transitioned into being a full time fan. I regularly attend major and minor league games when I have free time. I enjoy working at a baseball store. I’m in my senior year of high school and hope to major in Journalism or Sports Administration in college. Follow Bernie on Twitter (@BernieOlshansky).

Posted on August 23, 2012, in MLB Teams: Articles and Analysis and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 1 Comment.

  1. Courtesy of Phil Barth (Thanks Phil) this has happened another time before in August of 1960

%d bloggers like this: