Blog Archives

The Pinstripe Magic

Like us on Facebook here

Monday, May.20/2013

Yankee fans consistently criticize their General Managers decision making process despite the fact that the last four years have been substantial successes. Will Yankee fans come to appreciate Cashman’s ability to find value to help sustain success?

By Nicholas Rossoletti (Yankees Correspondent/Trade Correspondent): Follow @nross56

There is a tendency for certain fan bases to panic quickly because of past failures. It can be hard to put your faith blindly in an organization that has frequently disappointed you.

The other side of that coin is that certain ball clubs deserve a bit more rope on the organizational end because of a string of impressive results.

One organization has seen such an unbelievable string of successful regular seasons over the last two decades. The New York Yankees. Despite this success, the fans of the organization ride a roller coaster quite unlike anything else in sports.

Vernon Wells Going Yard in Colorado:

[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Eu7IGoYtndY]
Read the rest of this entry →

About these ads

Posted in MLB Teams: Articles and Analysis, The Rest: Everything Baseball

Leave a Comment

Tags: @drewdinkmeyer, @nross56, @nross56 twitter, adam warren, brian cashman, curtis granderson, david robertson, drew dinkmeyer, fantistics, mariano rivera, mark teixeira, new York, new york yankees, nicholas rossoletti, vernon wells, yankees

2 And A Hook Podcast Ep #5: What about WAR? + The Good, The Bad + Downright Underachieving Teams in 2013

May 16

Posted by mlbmaniac1373

Like us on Facebook here

Follow @mlbreports

Friday, May.17/2013

MLB reports and The Benchwarmers Show present 2 and A Hook Podcast.

People in this Podcast:

Chuck Booth – (`15 Minutes In – 15 Minute Segment) Guest (Lead Baseball Analyst/Website Owner): Follow @chuckbooth3024

By James Acevedo – Host (Podcast Veteran) Follow @yankeeman1973

’2 And A Hook’ is an expression from Baseball: ‘Throw the guy 2 Fast balls and then a Hook’ (AKA Curve Ball, Wiggly one, Chair etc..)

On today’s show, brought to you by MLB Reports (www.mlbreports.com) & yours truly ‘The Bench Warmers Show’, Chuck Booth Follow @chuckbooth3024 does his regular segment this time about what’s been going on the MLB Reports website & talking about what to do with the DH position with Adam Dunn, Steve Pearce & Nolan Reimold In the AL.

Plus the Baltimore franchise signing and pitching Freddy Garcia & why the Orioles should have added veteran pitching depth before the season started

Why Raul Ibanez being an underrated player & the horrible starts of their seasons by David Price & Rickie Weeks!

Also I talk to Diamondbacks correspondent for MLB Reports & for Rant Sports (www.rantsports.com) Chris Lacey 45 Minutes In (10 Minute Segment) Follow @aecanada12 - as we talk about whats going on with the team.

We also see the return of Yankees correspondent & trade correspondent for MLB Reports Nicholas Rossoletti (1 Hour In – 45 minute Segment) Follow @nross56 as we talk about the importance of the WAR stat, sabermetrics, lack of trading & why buying free agents isn’t working for the Angels, Dodgers & Blue Jays!

I also do my stats & notes segment as usual for you baseball nuts out there so go check out the show & SPREAD THE WORD!!! Thanks for all of your continuous support!!!

CLICK THE READ THE REST OF THIS ENTRY ICON or scroll down to listen to the episode Read the rest of this entry →

Posted in The Rest: Everything Baseball, MLB Teams: Articles and Analysis, MLB Podcast Network

Leave a Comment

Tags: moneyball, toronto blue jays, tampa bay rays, baltimore orioles, arizona diamondbacks, st louis cardinals, Atlanta Braves, oakland athletics, AL East, johan santana, phil hughes, vernon wells, don mattingly, travis hafner, mark buehrle, cc sabathia, ken griffey jr, alex rodriguez, matt kemp, seattle mariners, cleveland indians, derek jeter, fantasy baseball, joba chamberlain, hector noesi, new york mets, yankee stadium, nl west, pnc park, prince fielder, milwaukee brewers, carlos beltran, philadelphia phillies, melky cabrera, matt cain, clayton kershaw, david price, hanley ramirez, pittsburgh pirates, mariano rivera, robinson cano, AL West, san francisco giants, brian cashman, los angeles dodgers, andre ethier, tim lincecum, justin upton, troy tulowitzki, Sparky Anderson, kirk gibson, zack greinke, jose reyes, craig kimbrel, lyle overbay, andy pettitte, rickie weeks, fernando rodney, adrian gonzalez, at and t park, paul goldschmidt, kyle lohse, carlos gonzalez, jim johnson, rafael soriano, Luke Scott, lou gehrig, francisco liriano, matt carpenter, ja happ, Patrick Corbin, Bob Melvin, bucky dent, pete kozma, @Nross56 on twitter, Hyun-Jin Ryu, AL Cy Young Award Winner, fangraphs.com, @aecanada12 on twitter, @sullybaseball on twitter, NL Cy young award winner, Sully Baseball, @yankeeman1973 on twitter, @MLBreports on twitter, Bobby Parnell, The Benchwarmers Show, angel hernandez, jordany valdespin, Los Angels Angels, John Sterling, MLB Reports Podcast Network, www.rantsports.com, Stump Merrill, 1995 ALDS, 2011 NLDS, A.J. Hinch, baseballreference.com, Hyung-jin Ryu

Trust In Cash: Vernon Wells And Getting Through Early 2013

Apr 1

Posted by nross56

Like us on Facebook here

Follow @mlbreports

Monday April.1, 2013

Our own Chuck Booth predicted that Mr. Wells could be wearing pinstripes this season and low and behold, Chuck was right. Now, to see if Wells can bridge the gap for the Yankees until Curtis Granderson returns.

Our own Chuck Booth predicted that Mr. Wells could be wearing pinstripes this season and lo and behold, Chuck was right. Now, to see if Wells can bridge the gap for the Yankees until Curtis Granderson returns.

By Nicholas Rossoletti (Yankees + Trade Correspondent) Follow @NRoss56

There have been few moments as divisive for Yankees fans over the past year than last weekend’s trade for Vernon Wells. While I will get to the trade analysis of the Wells deal, I find it incredibly interesting the conversations and general disdain Yankee fans are currently showing for the management team in the Bronx.

The Yankee universe took to social media after the announcement of the trade. A large contingent were calling for Brian Cashman’s job, which I’m sure is not anything unusual for the General Manager of the Yankees. It did get me thinking about where the team is coming into the season.

Vernon Wells Highlights – Parental Guidance is Advised:

Read the rest of this entry →

Posted in MLB Teams: Articles and Analysis, The Rest: Everything Baseball

1 Comment

Tags: @nross56 twitter, AL East, alex rodriguez, anaheim angels, brian cashman, Chuck Booth, curtis granderson, david phelps, derek jeter, eric chavez, gary sanchez, lyle overbay, mariano rivera, mark teixeira, new York, new york yankees, nicholas rossoletti, nick swisher, phil hughes, raul ibanez, russell martin, slade heathcott, tyler austin, vernon wells, yankee stadium

Sully Baseball Daily Podcast – March 4, 2013

Mar 4

Posted by Paul Francis Sullivan

Trout had 49 SB, 129 Runs 30 HRs and 83 RBI in just 138 Games. Might he improve on these numbers with a full year and the addition of Josh Hamilton to the cleanup spot in 2013?

Mike Trout will be making $500,000 as a 21 year old. Chances are that’s more than you made when you were his age.

What is stupider? The outrage over Mike Trout’s contract or Brian Cashman skydiving and breaking his ankle.

Those are the topics on The Sully Baseball Daily Podcast.

Subscribe to The Sully Baseball Daily Podcast on iTunes here.

Posted in MLB Podcast Network, The Rest: Everything Baseball

Leave a Comment

Tags: brian cashman, Mike Trout

New York Yankees Payroll In 2013 And Contracts Going Fwd Updated Mar.4/2013

Mar 4

Posted by chuckbooth3023

Like us on Facebook here

Follow @mlbreports

Monday, March.04/2013

You are looking at the #1 and #2 Hits Leaders of ALL-Time for Active Professional Hitters in the World. Having them hit 1-2 in the lineup only makes sense. You might as well have them both retire at the same timeJeter is signed for one more year at 17 Million Dollars plus a player option ($8 MIL) for 2014. The Yankees signed Ichiro to a 2 year deal worth $13 MIL this past winter.

Chuck Booth (Lead Baseball Analyst/Website Owner): Follow @chuckbooth3024

I am not like a lot of people thinking that there should be a full-scale blow-up of the Yankees current roster this year (past that I am acknowledging this will happen.) They are old and 2013 will not make them younger. However, there are some small tweaks that the team could do in order to make the payroll make sense. 1st priority was to sign Ichiro Suzuki.

The Japanese Superstar was not and Yankees obliged to let him play RF in New York. Adios to outgoing Nick Swisher. He was much too pricey and Yankee fans have to be sick at his lack of production in his playoff career. Swisher commanded a nice 4 or 5 year deal in the 56 – 70 Million Dollar Range from the Indians - and was not a fit into the Yankees current payroll structure.

The Yankees were initially looking to spend just a little over 178 Million Dollars in 2013, but that didn’t happen. At a 40% penalty (for every dollar spent over the 178 Million Mark) for abusing the Luxury Tax Threshold, the team will need to have made financial considerations in moving forward each time they sign another new player. Curtis Granderson and Robinson Cano are on the last year of their contracts. Mark Teixeira, CC Sabathia and A-Rod still have multiple years left in their contracts.

I would immediately move Alex Rodriguez to a permanent DH (when he returns to the lineup) - and play Kevin Youkilis at 3B for all of 2013.

To the Readers on our Payroll Breakdowns: Keep in mind these are all just estimates as we are all not forensic payroll accountants. For a better look at how Payrolls work in the MLB please check out this article here.

Derek Jeter Highlights:

Read the rest of this entry →

Posted in MLB Payroll and Contracts, The Rest: Everything Baseball

4 Comments

Tags: 2013 Yankee Payroll, a, alex rodriguez, andruw jones, andy pettitte, anibal sanchez, b.j. upton, boone logan, brian cashman, casey mcehee, cc sabathia, cesar cabrel, chris stewart, Chuck Booth. fastest 30 ballgames, clay rapada, cody ross, curtis granderson, dave robertson, david phelps, dellin betances, derek jeter, derek lowe, eduardo nunez, eric chavez, freddy garcia, Hal steinbrenner, ichiro suzuki, ivan nova, j. burnett, jonathan broxton, juan pierre, justin thomas, kevin youkilis, mariano rivera, mark teixeira, matt garza, michael bourn, michael pineda, new york yankees, nick swisher, pedro feliciano, phil hughes, rafael soriano, raul ibanez, reed johnson, robinson cano, russell martin, ryan madson, travis hafner, twitter @chuckbooth3024

Granderson Is Out For 10 Weeks: What Can Cashman Do?

Feb 25

Posted by chuckbooth3023

Like us on Facebook here

Follow @mlbreports

Monday, February.25, 2013

Granderson has back to back 40 HR years with the Yankees. New York can ill afford to be without a productive LF for the 1st quarter of the year. I believe they should make a trade to bolster their team. When Granderson comes back, you could always have an extra player for depth still.

Granderson has had back to back 40 HR years with the Yankees in 2011 and 2012. New York can ill afford to be without a productive LF for the 1st quarter of this season. I believe they should make a trade to bolster their team. When Granderson comes back, you would always have an extra player for depth still.

Chuck Booth (Yankees Correspondent/Website Owner): Follow @chuckbooth3024

The start of the season is starting to look extremely bleak for the Yankees so far. Derek Jeter is coming off of a broken ankle, A-Rod is out indefinitely with (insert whatever ailment here) until after the ALL-Star Game, Mariano Rivera is 43 – and trying to make it through one more season after tearing up his ACL last year, Phil Hughes is having back spasms, Joba Chamberlain seems healthy – (but you never what freak injury is going to happen to him next,) Michael Pineda is still recovering from shoulder Surgery, so what else was going to happen? Add Curtis Granderson and a fractured right forearm to the walking wounded list.

This injury should alarm the Yankees and their fans. The team is not strong depth-wise, as they have been in decades, so “The ‘Grandy Man’ not being able to play until early May should cause New York GM Brian Cashman to explore all of his options. Like I have said in previous articles – ‘Financial Armageddon’ is coming for the club in 2014, plus the team is rapidly becoming older by the year. It is safe to say that this year might be the last kick at a championship for some time. What may the Yankees do to replace Granderson for the 1st quarter of the season?

Juan Rivera hits a Walk-Off for the Dodgers:

Read the rest of this entry →

Posted in The Rest: Everything Baseball

Leave a Comment

Tags: Adam Eaton, AL East, alex presley, alex rodriguez, alfonso soriano, anaheim stadium, Andrew McCutchen, andy pettitte, arizona diamondbacks, boone logan, brett gardner, brian cashman, bryce harper, Carlos lee, carlos zambrano, chicago cubs, clay rapada, cody eppley, cody ross, david aardsma, david robertson, dellin betances, derek jeter, garrett jones, gerardo parra, ichiro suzuki, ivan nova, jason kubel, jayson werth, joba chamberlain, Jose Tabata, juan rivera, los angeles angels of anaheim, manny banuelos, mariano rivera, mason williams, melky mesa, michael pineda, new york yankees, peter bourjos, phil hughes, pittsburgh pirates, ryan madson, steve lombardozzi, the bronx bombers, Tommy John Surgery, top 100 2013 MLB prospects, travis hafner, travis snider, twitter @chuckbooth3024, vernon wells, yankee stadium

The New York Yankees Hitting Roster In 2013: State Of The Union Part 1

Feb 13

Posted by chuckbooth3023

Like us on Facebook here

Follow @mlbreports

Wednesday, February.13, 2013

The Yankees have 27 World Series Titles and 13 Losses in the Fall Classic since 1921. That is 40 Appearances in 91 years. They have had the highest payroll team in MLB for the Majority of that span. As of 2013, they will not be able to claim that stake anymore. Will they still make the playoffs for the 18th time in 19 years?

Chuck Booth (Yankees Correspondent/Website Owner): Follow @chuckbooth3024

The Yankees had a precarious winter after failing miserably in the ALCS, (AKA the last time the country saw them play on Television) – when the team was decimated by the Detroit Tigers in a sweep. So what has happened since? A lot of status quo: Re-signing Mariano Rivera, Andy Pettitte, Ichiro Suzuki and Hiroki Kuroda, while saying good-bye to Raul Ibanez (SEA), Andruw Jones (FA), Nick Swisher (CLE), Eric Chavez (ARI), Russell Martin (PIT), Derek Lowe (FA), Steve Pearce (BAL), Casey McGehee (FA), Freddy Garcia (FA) and Rafael Soriano (WSH). All they really added back was former arch-nemesis Kevin Youkilis (CWS) and Travis Hafner (CLE). The team is sitting around 215 Million Dollars at Payroll right now, yet they have are heading into the 2013 campaign with Catchers that are of limited experience.

For the first time in years, the club will need to see some internal progress from their farm system to help the big club. With A-ROD out with his hip injury, plus the Miami fiasco, can you really count on the prima-donna to play at all this season? Derek Jeter is coming off a brutal ankle injury that occurred in the aforementioned Post Season Series vs the Tigers . The club is also hoping that ‘MO’ Rivera can find it within himself to make it through another year as a 43 Year Old. Just like The ALL-Time Saves Leader, this team is aging fast. Robinson Cano and Curtis Granderson are Free Agents after 2013 is over. Brian Cashman is also going to take advantage of the reset option f the Luxury Tax loophole in 2014.

This means that when the Luxury Tax goes from 178 Million to 189 Million next year, that the club can stop paying its 40% annual penalty if they can get under for just one season. The Yankees will be sure to blow up the Payroll from 2015 and beyond that, it is just to not start the new luxury lax at the maximum penalty. Had the Luxury Tax not moved from its current spot, the Yankees would always pay the 40% penalty (even if they decided to skip one year).

Yankees Highlights 2012: Mature Lyrics So Parental Guidance is Advised:

Read the rest of this entry →

Posted in MLB Payroll and Contracts, The Rest: Everything Baseball

Leave a Comment

Tags: 2009 World Series, 2012 ALCS, 2013 Yankee Payroll, 25 man roster New York Yankees, 40 Man Roster Yankees, a, al mvp, AL Silver Slugger Award Winners, alex rodriguez, all time hits list, all-time home run list, andruw jones, andy pettitte, austine romine, boston red sox, brian cashman, casey mcehee, chicago white sox, chris stewart, Chuck Booth. fastest 30 ballgames, cleveland indians, curtis granderson, dave robertson, dellin betances, derek jeter, derek lowe, detroit tigers, eddie collins, eduardo nunez, eric chavez, francisco cervelli, freddy garcia, Gold Glove Award Winner AL, Hal steinbrenner, hiroki kuroda, ichiro suzuki, john buck, johnny damon, jonathan broxton, juan pierre, kevin youkilis, kurt suzuki, mariano rivera, mark teixeira, new york yankees, nick swisher, paul molitor, phil hughes, rafael soriano, raul ibanez, robinson cano, russell martin, ryan madson, seattle mariners, stan musial, steve pearce, thurman munson, travis hafner, twitter @chuckbooth3024, Wilson Ramos

Its A Big Year For Yankees SP Phil Hughes And RP Joba Chamberlain

Feb 4

Posted by chuckbooth3023

Like us on Facebook here

Follow @mlbreports

Tuesday, February.04/2013

Heading into 2013, Hughes has a Career Record of 52-36 (.591) – with a 4.39 ERA. He is projected to be the #4 starter for the Yankees in 2013. He is 46-34, with a 4.68 ERA for his Career as a Starter opposed to a Reliever – where he was 5-1, with a 1.40 ERA during 2009.

By Chuck Booth (Yankees Correspondent/Website Owner): Follow @chuckbooth3024

Phil Hughes represents a nice #3 or #4 starter for the New York Yankees – and Joba Chamberlain will be counted on more than ever with Rafael Soriano not being back in the bullpen for 2013. This will be his 7th season in the ‘Bronx for both Pitchers. The 6 Foot 5 native (Hughes) of California, is coming off a decent season in 2012 – after he struggled with arm fatigue in 2011. Chamberlain has had a litany of injuries pile up on his 6 Foot 2, 250 LBS frame over the last several years. Yankees fans all know too well how this man and Joba Chamberlain have been bounced to and from the Starting Rotation to the Relief Corps. I think it is safe to say the Yankees finally have it right. Joba is a reliever and Hughes is a Starting Pitcher.

The Yankees have them both locked up on one year deals for 2013. Chamberlain will make 1.88 Million Dollars – while Hughes will make 7.15 Million Dollars. With an aging offense this year, the Yankees will be counting on several internal improvements amongst their pitching staffs. These two veterans will need to take it to the next level based on their projections of talent.

Joba Chamberlain – How To Be Awesome

Read the rest of this entry →

Posted in The Rest: Everything Baseball

2 Comments

Tags: 2009 World Series, 2012 ALCS, 2012 ALDS, @chuckbooth3024 on twitter, a.j. burnett, AL ALL-Star Appearances, AL East, Al rookie of the year, American league, andy pettitte, brian cashman, carl pavano, cc sabathia, chien-ming wang, Chuck Booth. fastest 30 ballgames, david robertson, ed whitson, hideki irabu, hiroki kuroda, ian kennedy, ivan nova, joba chamberlain, JOBA Rules, mariano rivera, matt wieters, mike mussina, phil hughes, stephen strasburg, Tommy John Surgery, yankee stadium, yankees relievers, Yankees starters

The Yankees Will Surpass A 200 Million Dollar Payroll in 2013 And Are Pinching Pennies At Catcher!

Dec 27

Posted by chuckbooth3023

Follow @mlbreports

Like us on Facebook here

Thursday, December.27, 2012

This guy might be a great defensive catcher when all is said and done, but how can you trust this team with a rookie catcher with their limited window to win?

Chuck Booth (Yankees Correspondent/Website Owner): Follow @chuckbooth3024

As of this very moment, you are not the happiest of campers if you are a Yankees fan. Francisco Cervelli, Chris Stewart and Austin Romine look to start the year out catching for the Bronx Bombers! Really??? You are telling me that you will spend 215-225 Million Dollars on (Luxury Taxable) Payroll and you couldn’t find a mere 7.5 Million for a 1 Year Deal to sign A.J. Pierzynski? The club will receive some insurance money for A-Rod’s injury this year, however the Luxury Tax is not affected by that. So maybe knowing that they will pay 40% more for a guys salary (more than he really makes as a salary) is another thing stalling the franchise from plunking some serious cash down on a real quality veteran catcher. In my opinion, this is a brutal mistake that will leave the fans frustrated beyond belief if it blows up in the Yankees face. The good news is that if the team is playing well in every other department other than the Catchers position, they can always address the situation at any point next year by a trade. With no significant catchers left on the FA Market, New York will probably go this route. If you can manage to keep atop of the standings, then you may land a veteran catcher that will only have a pro-rated salary for the rest of the year.

If I were Ichiro Suzuki, Derek Jeter, Mariano Rivera or Andy Pettitte, I would not be happy with the club not landing a proven offensive or defensive catcher. (Boy does that Jesus Montero Trade not look so favorable right now.) These 4 veterans are in the last year or two of their contracts and possibly their careers will end once their contracts. While these guys would never panic, you only need to look what the Blue Jays are doing north of the border for real ‘transaction aggression.’ I just think that you have re-signed and brought in Free Agents that all point to a “Win Now” mentality, yet you are going towards one-dimensional catchers that all have limited experience. It doesn’t feel right and the Yankees ‘Faithful’ will have a field day on Management and ownership should this position end up being a crutch on the teams success chances for 2013.

Read the rest of this entry →

Posted in The Rest: Everything Baseball

Leave a Comment

Tags: AL East, andy petttitte, austin romine, boone logan, boston red sox, brady gardner, brian cashman, cc sabathia, chris stewart, Chuck Booth. fastest 30 ballgames, cody eppley, curtis granderson, david phelps, derek jeter, eduardo nunez, francisco cervelli, george steinbrenner, hiroki kuroda, jesus montero, joba chamberlain, joe girardi, josh hamilton, kevin youkilis, kurt suzuki, Luxury Tax Threshold, manuel banuelos, mark teixeira, mike napoli, new york mets, new york yankees, phil hughes, robinson cano, russell martin, scranton wilkes barre, st louis cardinals, texas rangers, thurman munson, toronto blue jays, twitter @chuckbooth3024, Wilson Ramos, World Series 2009, Yankees Management, Yankees Payroll 2013, yankees payroll 2014

The Yankees Should sign Vlad Guerrero

Jun 13

Posted by chuckbooth3023

Follow @mlbreports

Wednesday June.13, 2012

Chuck Booth (Lead Baseball Writer and @chuckbooth3024 on twitter)- The events that happened yesterday with the Blue Jays and Vlad Guerrero are strange and totally warranted for further review. In my opinion, the Blue Jays dropped the ball on this one. Guerrero lit up the Minor Leagues for a couple of weeks and should have been called up when Edwin Encarnacion was hurt on June.4th. It was the perfect opportunity to have Vladdy come up and replace EE in the lineup. It should have prompted a return to first base for Encarnacion when he came back from his injury just 5 days later.

The top average on the team actually belongs to EE, who is hitting .281 currently. Vlad Guerrero has never hit worst than .290 in the last 15 years. He tore it up in the minor leagues, and was said to have showed up in decent shape. The Blue Jays had to know that Vladdy would be upset when he was bypassed on in favor of David Cooper or Yan Gomes. I give full credit to the agent for Guerrero in this case, he negotiated a verbal contract with Alex Anthopoulos that the slugger could opt at any time and request to be released from his player contract with the club. In the only thing that makes the Jays look okay on this, they never had to go through with letting Vladdy out of this contract. Really it is a shame that the two sides could not work out something to have Vlad stay with the club. It may actually work out better for both sides in the long run.

Read the rest of this entry →

Posted in The Rest: Everything Baseball

1 Comment

Tags: alex anthopoulos, alex rodriguez, andruw jones, blue jays, brett gardner, brett lawrie, brian cashman, Chuck Booth, colby rasmus, curtis granderson, david cooper, derek jeter, edwin encarnacion, jose bautista, mark teixeira, new York, nick swisher, raul banez, russell martin, the fastest 30 ballgames, vladimir guerrero, yan gomes, yankees, yunel escobar

Michael Pineda’s Early Demise

Follow @mlbreports

Saturday April 28th, 2012

Bernie Olshansky: Exactly one year ago today, Michael Pineda was just a few starts into his major league career. He had a fastball upwards of ninety-five miles per hour and seemed to be the next Felix Hernandez in the Mariners organization. It would have been impossible to predict where he is now and what he is going through. The Yankees announced Wednesday that Pineda would miss the rest of the season due to an anterior labrum tear in his shoulder and would need to undergo arthroscopic surgery. The best-case recovery time is 12 months, making a return for Opening Day 2013 nearly impossible.

A shoulder injury is one of the worst possible injuries a pitcher could have. Compared to elbow injuries and the recovery from Tommy John surgery, the recovery from a torn labrum is a much longer and tougher process. Pineda most likely suffered this injury due to fatigue from his large workload last year (171.0 IP). The good news for Pineda is that the rotator cuff is not damaged, and the surgery is successful 85-90 percent of the time. A couple of recent pitchers who recovered successfully from this type of surgery are Curt Schilling and Chris Carpenter. Schilling had a similar injury in 1995 when he was 28 years old, which caused him to miss most of the 1995 season. For Schilling, it only took ten months to fully recover and by May 1996, he was pitching again. Carpenter tore his labrum in 2003 and made a full recovery to come back to have a great 2004 season. Pineda’s return isn’t impossible by any means, especially because he just turned 23. Talk about a sophomore jinx for Pineda — he didn’t even get to start his sophomore campaign.

Unfortunately for the Yankees, their highly touted prize in the Jesus Montero trade must be placed on the disabled list for the rest of this season. Mariners GM Jack Zduriencik claims he had no knowledge whatsoever about a possible injury for Pineda when he made the trade, so it seems that the Yankees just got unlucky. At the time of the trade, it seemed that both teams were getting a great deal for each of their needs. The Yankees needed pitching and got exactly that from Pineda with a solid 3.74 ERA in his Rookie year with 171.0 innings pitched and 173 strikeouts. This type of performance earned him All Star honors. The only concern was the large number of innings pitched, which, in my opinion, ended up doing him in. The Mariners, knowing that they were going to have sufficient pitching in the future with Felix Hernandez and highly regarded prospect Danny Hultzen, traded Pineda for Yankees prospect Jesus Montero who was ready to be on the big club after spending the majority of 2011 in the minors (tearing it up, I might add with an overall .308 average over a five-year span). For the anemic Mariners offense that needed some pop, Montero promised to help improve a club that, in 2011 ranked dead last in average, runs, slugging percentage, on base percentage, and 25th in home runs. This already perfect deal for the Mariners turned out even better sadly when Pineda went down with this injury.

Now the Yankees are stuck with an injured Pineda, and do not have Jesus Montero in their lineup (who was hitting .263 as of today, but hey, at least he’s playing). The Mariners also got pitcher Hector Noesi, who is also part of the Mariners’ rotation, and the Yankees received minor league pitcher Jose Campos, who has posted a 1.23 ERA so far for the Charleston RiverDogs Single-A team (I guess that’s the only silver lining for the Yankees). Five years from now when all of the players who were involved in the trade are established major leaguers, this may all be a distant memory. But right now for the Yankees, it hurts a lot.

**Today’s feature was prepared by Bernie Olshanksy, MLB reports Intern candidate. We highly encourage you to leave your comments and feedback at the bottom of the page and share in the discussion with our readers. You can also follow Bernie on Twitter. (@BernieOlshansky)***

Please e-mail us at: mlbeports@me.com with any questions and feedback. You can follow us on Twitter and become a fan on Facebook . To subscribe to our website and have the daily Reports sent directly to your inbox , click here and follow the link at the top of our homepage.

Follow @mlbreports

Posted on April 28, 2012 | Image

Michael Pineda is Out for the Year: When Will the Yankees Pitcher Return?

Apr 27

Posted by samevans87

Follow @mlbreports

Friday April 27th, 2012

Sam Evans: On this past Wednesday, we learned that twenty-three year old Yankees starting pitcher Michael Pineda was diagnosed with an anterior labral tear, and that he will undergo surgery on May 1st. Pineda is definitely out for the year, and there is a chance he could never pitch in the majors again. There is talk though that he could be out for less than a year and come back stronger than ever. But that possibility is hopeful at best. Thus is the nature of Pineda’s situation. Let’s take a look at his injury, and when the Yankees could hope to see him pitching in New York.

When Michael Pineda was acquired from the Mariners this offseason, Yankees fans were feeling pretty good about their rotation. They had just traded for one of the top young arms in the majors. In 2011, Pineda was an All-Star and started twenty-eight incredible games for the Mariners. He barely had any issues with control, he struck out a ton of batters, and he had the poise of a veteran. He wore down as the season came to an end, but that was normal given his age and experience. Even though the Yankees gave up two talented players to get Pineda and a prospect, he had a chance to be the #2 starter that they were looking for when they signed A.J. Burnett. Read the rest of this entry →

Posted in MLB Player Profiles

Leave a Comment

Tags: AL East, baseball, brian cashman, jesus montero, joe girardi, labrum, michael pineda, mlb, new york yankees, seattle mariners, starting pitcher, surgery

Memo to Brian Cashman: “Time to Trade A.J. Burnett”

Follow @mlbreports

Saturday February 11th 2012

MLB reports – Jonathan Hacohen: I have been working on this note to Mr. Cashman that I wanted to share with you today. Partially because I haven’t really been working on this note for very long. Also, I never actually planned to send it to the Yankees GM. From the sounds of his current state of affairs, Brian has his hands full and probably would not have much time to read my message. But considering the marriage of the New York Yankees and A.J. Burnett, I think a resolution is needed. Immediately. My solution? Let’s read the letter and find out: (more…)