2011 MLB All-Star Game Ballots: American League Vote Totals

Tuesday June 14, 2011

 

 

 

MLB reports:  In part II of our All-Star game feature, we take a look at the leading vote getters for the American League squad.  The MLB All-Star Game is coming up on July 12th from Phoenix, Arizona.  With home field advantage on the line, the question every year is whether the American League will continue its domination in the mid-season classic.  We might as well call this team the New York Red Sox or Boston Yankees given the current composition of the team.  Let’s take a look at the AL vote totals as of today to consider if the fans are getting it right:

 

CATCHER
Russell Martin, Yankees: 1,712,156
Alex Avila, Tigers: 1,093,070
Joe Mauer, Twins: 1,041,798
Jarrod Saltalamacchia, Red Sox: 763,607
Yorvit Torrealba, Rangers: 751,858

Verdict:  Round one goes to the fans as Russell Martin for the most part has been the best catcher in the American League thus far.  Coming off an unproductive, injury filled 2010 season, Martin has rebounded to reclaim his all-star status.  The 2nd leading vote getter, Alex Avila, has enjoyed a breakthrough campaign and deserves to be up high on the list.  From there, the waters get murky.  Mauer has been injured all year and Salmatlamacchia has been fairly unproductive for most of the season in Boston.  Names like Arencebia and Suzuki should probably be higher up on the list, as much of this list is based on past production and/or popularity vs. actual production.  But Martin is in the lead for being the best catcher in the AL, as much as he is a Yankee.

 

FIRST BASE
Adrian Gonzalez, Red Sox: 2,027,537
Mark Teixeira, Yankees: 1,774,024
Miguel Cabrera, Tigers: 1,295,547
Mitch Moreland, Rangers: 692,670
Paul Konerko, White Sox: 507,547

Verdict:  One of the early season picks for MVP, Gonzalez has been everything that could have been expected and more for Boston.  Teixeira and Cabrera have also enjoyed productive campaigns and are rightfully at the top of the voting leader board.  A case could be made for any of the three to start at first in Arizona, but A-Gonz has been the best of the bunch and deserves to be at the top.  He just happens to play in Boston as well.

 

SECOND BASE
Robinson Cano, Yankees: 2,649,737
Dustin Pedroia, Red Sox: 1,518,231
Ian Kinsler, Rangers: 1,129,023
Orlando Cabrera, Indians: 732,308
Ben Zobrist, Rays: 633,533

Verdict:  A Yankee in first and a Red Sox player in 2nd in this category.  Are we noticing a trend?  Based on numbers alone, Cano has been far and away the best second baseman in the American League, if not all of baseball.  With almost double the amount of votes compared to Pedroia, fans clearly agree.  The list, one through five, appears to be bang-on with listing the top players at the position.  The fans got it right yet again. 

 

THIRD BASE
Alex Rodriguez, Yankees: 2,063,520
Adrian Beltre, Rangers: 1,752,729
Kevin Youkilis, Red Sox: 1,381,381
Evan Longoria, Rays: 1,226,770
Maicer Izturis, Angels: 364,623

Verdict:  This is not your father’s third base and while this group used to be the elite of the league, the numbers are showing otherwise.  With Longoria injured for must of the campaign, A-Rod continues to be the leading voting getter with Beltre close behind.  I was very surprised to see Longoria as high as 4th, but based on his strong image and popularity, I guess it should have been expected.  A-Rod based on the number deserves this spot, but is here as much for his numbers as the fact that he is a Yankee.  His position as the top player in the game has clearly been eroding for some time.  But for this season at least, A-Rod looks to remain the top third baseman in the American League.

 

SHORTSTOP
Derek Jeter, Yankees: 1,931,670
Asdrubal Cabrera, Indians: 1,647,802
Elvis Andrus, Rangers: 1,180,962
Yunel Escobar, Blue Jays: 640,395
Jhonny Peralta, Tigers: 540,601

Verdict:  Much outcry has been heard over this vote and I will agree.  For a player that has given so much to the game, Derek Jeter on the numbers does not deserve to be starting in the All-Star game.  Cabrera, Andrus and Escobar have enjoyed very productive seasons for their respective teams and should be ahead of Jeter in the voting.  But alas Jeter is Jeter and the fans have chosen the sizzle over the steak in this case.  A big double thumbs down here.

 

DESIGNATED HITTER
David Ortiz, Red Sox: 1,974,918
Michael Young, Rangers: 1,428,833
Jorge Posada, Yankees: 810,672
Travis Hafner, Indians: 691,205
Johnny Damon, Rays: 672,529

Verdict:  The designated hitter, the who’s-who of players playing out the string in the American League.  Despite strong seasons by Young, Hafner and Damon, it is David Ortiz who has been the best DH of 2011 and as a result has a huge lead in the voting.  Jorge Posada should be near the bottom of the pack, but sits in third place based on his name and team.  Anyone here besides Ortiz would have been an injustice.

 

OUTFIELD
Jose Bautista, Blue Jays: 3,042,091
Curtis Granderson, Yankees: 2,406,946
Josh Hamilton, Rangers: 1,799,339
Jacoby Ellsbury, Red Sox: 1,447,715
Ichiro Suzuki, Mariners: 1,231,035
Carl Crawford, Red Sox: 1,222,687
Nelson Cruz, Rangers: 1,123,608
Nick Swisher, Yankees: 937,365
Brett Gardner, Yankees: 796,905
J.D. Drew, Red Sox: 778,871
Jeff Francoeur, Royals: 752,687
Grady Sizemore, Indians: 739,930
Matt Joyce, Rays: 737,377
Shin-Soo Choo, Indians: 642,387
David Murphy, Rangers: 622,160

Verdict:  I will give the fans credit.  Two out of three ain’t bad.  The top two outfielders in the American League have been Bautista and Granderson.  They sit one and two in the lead to be the starting outfielders in Arizona.  Bravo fans.  Bravo.  Josh Hamilton though sits in third place over Jacoby Ellsbury.  Based on last year’s campaign, Hamilton was a far stronger player than Ellsbury.  But this year, Hamilton has missed much of the season due to injury while Ellsbury has rebounded.  Despite the heavy Red Sox and Yankees mix in the lineup, I would have awarded Ellsebury the third outfield spot if given the choice between the two.  But looking at the rest of the voting list, it is beyond me how Swisher, Gardner, Crawford and Drew are at the voting list.  Aside from playing in Boston and New York, these players have done literally nothing to earn their votes.  I am impressed to see Francoeur and Joyce with strong vote totals, proving that smaller names in even smaller markets can still be rewarded for strong play.  Ichiro is also on the list despite one of his worst campaigns ever.  Where I ask is Carlos Quentin, one of the top hitters this year in the American League?  Playing for a poor White Sox team with little attention this year.  King Carlos should be starting, but the popularity contest unfortunately did him in. 

 

 

 

If the voting for the American League All-Star team ended today, 7/9 of the starting lineup would be made up of Red Sox and Yankees players.  While most of the players deserve their positions based on the numbers, it would be curious to see what would happen if those same players were on different teams.  But then if those players were on different teams, they may not end up with the same high numbers they are producing.  Very perplexing.  It would be nice to have greater balance in the voting to include more players from other squads.  But when players like Russell Martin, David Ortiz and Curtis Granderson stand out so far from the crowd, they should be voted in regardless of the city they play in.  While the bias of fans then results in Derek Jeter starting and inferior players like Drew and Swisher receiving high vote totals, looking at the lineups overall, the fans for the most part got it right.  For those critics that do not agree, the best argument is get as many fans from other cities to vote on-line and at the games to make a difference.  But the fans have spoken and we look forward to watching the New York Red Sox take on the National League All-Star team in Arizona on July 12th.

Please click here to read yesterday’s NL All-Star team preview. 

 

Please e-mail us at: MLBreports@gmail.com with any questions and feedback.  You can follow us on Twitter and become a fan on Facebook .  To subscribe to our website and have the daily Reports sent directly to your inbox, click here and follow the link at the top of our homepage.

About these ads

About MLB reports

24/7 MLB talk, news, and reports: If baseball is your passion, this site is for you! Follow us on twitter at: http://www.twitter.com/MLBreports

Posted on June 14, 2011, in MLB Teams: Articles and Analysis, The Rest: Everything Baseball and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 1 Comment.

  1. I agree with most of your analysis with one big exception. Alex Avila is the best catcher in the AL this year, period! His stats are much better than Martin. The only thing he doesn’t have going for him is his uniform – no pinstripes.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 19,299 other followers

%d bloggers like this: